Why Good Leaders Do Bad Things
This article talks about why good leaders commit unethical acts and the five "mind games" that often lead to unethical behavior. The author talks about how to handle a managerial issue when it puts profits and ethics against each other. When dealing with a complex, challenging problem, we often make the mistake of over simplifying the problem at hand which leads to the wrong solution for the problem. Our need to be liked also tends to lead us to making the wrong decision in ethical situations. Another common mistake by managers is disguising the unethical issue. Often managers compare the unethical act to worse unethical acts to make the issue at hand seem not as severe. They also use words to make an act seem not as severe, such as referring to stealing as the “inappropriate allocation of resources”. The final thing that makes good leaders often do bad things is the thinking that they are above it all or bigger than the company.
Do you think that it is these five factors that cause good leaders to do bad? or are these people unethical to begin with and just masking their unethical behaviors?
Dave Holloway
Monday, April 11, 2011
Bad Leaders Fail!
http://web.hbr.org/email/archive/dailystat.php?date=060409 (Full Article)
In this article it talks about the top ten things a bad leader can possess. I think that it the chart fits right into authentic leadership. Authentic leadership can be viewed from three seperate view points: intrapersonal, developmental, and interpersonal. Each viewpoint is unique and helpful in clarifying the meaning of authentic leadership. Intrapersonal viewpoint is defined as focusing closely on the leader and what goes on within the leader. Developmental viewpoint is defined as something that can be nurtured in a leader, rather than as a fixed trait. Interpersonal viewpoint is defined as relational, created by leaders and followers together. (Northouse)

Eric Dhooge
In this article it talks about the top ten things a bad leader can possess. I think that it the chart fits right into authentic leadership. Authentic leadership can be viewed from three seperate view points: intrapersonal, developmental, and interpersonal. Each viewpoint is unique and helpful in clarifying the meaning of authentic leadership. Intrapersonal viewpoint is defined as focusing closely on the leader and what goes on within the leader. Developmental viewpoint is defined as something that can be nurtured in a leader, rather than as a fixed trait. Interpersonal viewpoint is defined as relational, created by leaders and followers together. (Northouse)
- Authentic leaders exhibit genuine leadership
- Authentic leaders lead from conviction
- Authentic leaders are original, not copies
- Authentic leaders base their actions on their values
Eric Dhooge
Greatest of the Worst!
http://media.www.westerncourier.com/media/storage/paper650/news/2007/02/16/Opinion/The-Eight.Worst.Leaders.Of.AllTime-2725590.shtml (For full article)
• Adolf Hitler (Germany; 1939-1945): No explanation should really be needed on this one.
• Mao ZeDong (China; 1958-61 and 1966-69): He founded the Chinese Communist party and was responsible for the deaths of more than 10 times as many people as Hitler.
• Joseph Stalin (USSR; 1929-1953): He launched "the Great Purge" in the 30s that rid the Communist Party of nearly every person who had brought him to power. According to a CNN article, Soviet nuclear physicist Andrei Sakharov estimated more than 1.2 million party members (more than half the group) were arrested, and 600,000 of those died by torture or execution.
• Pol Pot (Cambodia; 1975-1979): He was influenced by Mao's cultural revolution, and 25 percent of Cambodia's population died from starvation, overwork and executions in Pol Pot's attempt to form a Communist peasant farming society. He conducted deadly purges to rid the area of the "old society," and anyone suspected of being disloyal was shot or bludgeoned with an ax.
• Kim Jong-il (North Korea; 1994-present): In the world's most tightly controlled society, roughly 250,000 civilians are in "re-education camps" and a majority of the nation is malnourished. But maybe that's only because he is so "ronry."
• Robert Mugabe (Zimbabwe; 1980-present): While Africa isn't the greatest continent to live on, Zimbabwe has the world's highest inflation rate, an 80 percent employment rate and, since 1988, the life expectancy has dropped from age 62 to 38. In 2005, Mugabe launched Operation Murambatsvina ("clean the filth"), which forced the eviction of 700,000 people to "restore order and sanity."
• Omar al-Bashir (Sudan; 1989-present): His campaign of religious and ethnic persecution has ended the lives of 180,000 Darfur civilians and has driven over two million people from their homes.
-Vlad the Impaler (15th century): Author Bram Stoker based his signature character Dracula on him. However, "The Impaler" did not kill to feed but for the pleasure of watching others suffer. It has been said he caused more "rivers of blood" than any other tyrant in history. Dracula is a teddy bear compared to this guy.
It's too early to tell if Bush will go down in history in the company of the aforementioned, or the other obvious choices who weren't mentioned, including Mussolini, Saddam Hussein and the numerous monarchs who have killed people because they looked at them weirdly. Yes, thousands of Americans are dying under Bush's leadership, but at least they're dying while defending their nation
The article above states and lists the eight worst leaders of all time. In class we have been talking about Transformational Leadership and what goes with it to be a good leader. The term Transformational Leadership is defined as linked roles between leaders and their followers. For example leaders need followers and followers need leaders. In transformational leadership we also talked about the four I's. Idealized influence, Inspirational motivation, Intellectual stimulation, and Individualized consideration. By possessing these 4 I's you can make yourself more aware of becoming a better leader. However, possessing these doesn't make you an ethical leader. Some of these leaders possessed a lot of the 4 I's but were they used for good or bad.
For example, Adolf Hitler was one of the most well know public speakers ever but yet he didn't use it for a positive impact. He was very inspirational and idealized in Germany and with the nazis but he wasn't a good leader.
To be a good leader it takes more than just possessing certain traits like Transformational leadership. You have to be willing to use your ability for good and to pass on positive actions to your followers.
Eric Dhooge
• Adolf Hitler (Germany; 1939-1945): No explanation should really be needed on this one.
• Mao ZeDong (China; 1958-61 and 1966-69): He founded the Chinese Communist party and was responsible for the deaths of more than 10 times as many people as Hitler.
• Joseph Stalin (USSR; 1929-1953): He launched "the Great Purge" in the 30s that rid the Communist Party of nearly every person who had brought him to power. According to a CNN article, Soviet nuclear physicist Andrei Sakharov estimated more than 1.2 million party members (more than half the group) were arrested, and 600,000 of those died by torture or execution.
• Pol Pot (Cambodia; 1975-1979): He was influenced by Mao's cultural revolution, and 25 percent of Cambodia's population died from starvation, overwork and executions in Pol Pot's attempt to form a Communist peasant farming society. He conducted deadly purges to rid the area of the "old society," and anyone suspected of being disloyal was shot or bludgeoned with an ax.
• Kim Jong-il (North Korea; 1994-present): In the world's most tightly controlled society, roughly 250,000 civilians are in "re-education camps" and a majority of the nation is malnourished. But maybe that's only because he is so "ronry."
• Robert Mugabe (Zimbabwe; 1980-present): While Africa isn't the greatest continent to live on, Zimbabwe has the world's highest inflation rate, an 80 percent employment rate and, since 1988, the life expectancy has dropped from age 62 to 38. In 2005, Mugabe launched Operation Murambatsvina ("clean the filth"), which forced the eviction of 700,000 people to "restore order and sanity."
• Omar al-Bashir (Sudan; 1989-present): His campaign of religious and ethnic persecution has ended the lives of 180,000 Darfur civilians and has driven over two million people from their homes.
-Vlad the Impaler (15th century): Author Bram Stoker based his signature character Dracula on him. However, "The Impaler" did not kill to feed but for the pleasure of watching others suffer. It has been said he caused more "rivers of blood" than any other tyrant in history. Dracula is a teddy bear compared to this guy.
It's too early to tell if Bush will go down in history in the company of the aforementioned, or the other obvious choices who weren't mentioned, including Mussolini, Saddam Hussein and the numerous monarchs who have killed people because they looked at them weirdly. Yes, thousands of Americans are dying under Bush's leadership, but at least they're dying while defending their nation
The article above states and lists the eight worst leaders of all time. In class we have been talking about Transformational Leadership and what goes with it to be a good leader. The term Transformational Leadership is defined as linked roles between leaders and their followers. For example leaders need followers and followers need leaders. In transformational leadership we also talked about the four I's. Idealized influence, Inspirational motivation, Intellectual stimulation, and Individualized consideration. By possessing these 4 I's you can make yourself more aware of becoming a better leader. However, possessing these doesn't make you an ethical leader. Some of these leaders possessed a lot of the 4 I's but were they used for good or bad.
For example, Adolf Hitler was one of the most well know public speakers ever but yet he didn't use it for a positive impact. He was very inspirational and idealized in Germany and with the nazis but he wasn't a good leader.
To be a good leader it takes more than just possessing certain traits like Transformational leadership. You have to be willing to use your ability for good and to pass on positive actions to your followers.
Eric Dhooge
Monday, March 21, 2011
Are most leaders evil?
The article above asks the questions why are so many “evil leaders” at the top of many organizations. I don’t think that the leaders the author is referring to are evil, but instead they are probably transactional leaders, (9,1) Authority Compliance on the Managerial grid, and definitely do not place much focus on relationships. Transactional leadership focuses on the exchanges that occur between leaders and followers, where as transformational leadership is a process whereby a person engages with others and creates a connection that raises the level of motivation and morality in both the leader and the follower (Northouse). If this author’s assumption is right then the author is saying that most powerful leaders are transactional. If he is right then powerful leaders also do not place much attention to building relationships in the workplace. I personally disagree with the author because I think that it’s important for leaders to practice transformational leadership over transactional leadership. I think the reason the author feels this is way is because he doesn’t think that many leaders focus on relationships, and only focus on the tasks that need to be accomplished. I think the reason he thinks this is because many leaders who are high in organizations are hard workers and very motivated so they may be perceived as a jerk or “evil”. One example is Steve Jobs, who we talked about in class. This author and many other people probably perceive him as evil because of his persona. Others however define him as transformational because his tactics could be seen as extremely motivational. Do you agree with the author that there are many “evil leaders” high up in organizations, or do you think he is over reacting? Also, do you know of any examples where transformational leaders with good ethics are successful (because apparently this author cannot)?
Jack Kalita
Team 5
Unethical Leader
The article above is about a controversial leader Hashim Thaci, being appointed president of Kosovo for the second time. This doesn’t seem to make much sense because parliament walked out in disgust when they realized Thaci was to become appointed for a second term. This seems extremely unethical because Thaci has been involved in a lot of illegal and unethical business in the past. As the article states, Thaci was linked to organized crime and organ trafficking in Europe last month.
As our book states, ethics are concerned with the kinds of values and morals an individual or society fins desirable or appropriate. It is pretty evident that the people of Kosovo are outraged by Thaci becoming president again. Many of the members or parliament did not even participate in the vote because they knew Thaci was going to win anyway, so they walked out in rebellion. It is pretty clear that Thaci is participating with the ethical egoism approach to moral conduct. There are three different approaches, ethical egoism, utilitarianism, and altruism. Ethical egoism states that a person will act to create the greatest good for herself or himself. Utilitarianism states that leaders should behave to create the greatest good for the greatest overall number of people. The idea of altruism states that a leader’s actions are moral if their primary purpose is to promote the best interests of others. It is pretty clear that Thaci’s approach is neither utilitarian nor altruistic, considering almost half of parliament walked out during the vote for the president. Thaci is definitely acting with ethical egoism. He clearly does not care about the people of Kosovo, and acts in selfish, sometimes illegal ways. He has been involved in several illegal/unethical crimes and has not provided the leadership the people of Kosovo need. What do you think about Hashim Thaci being appointed president? Do you think it can be argued that this is somehow ethical?
Jack Kalita
Team 5
Sunday, March 20, 2011
Do Women Leaders Matter?
http://kristof.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/03/08/do-women-leaders-matter/
In this article it talks about if women leaders really do matter. As stated in the last post by Eric, women are transformational types of leaders and care about the feelings of their followers. But, does a women leader always do the right thing for their followers. This article states, "Bangladesh has a woman prime minister, Sheikh Hasina, who has done nothing much for women – and who now is pursuing a campaign of vilification against Muhammad Yunus, the Nobel Peace Prize winner who has been a champion of impoverished women all around the globe." To me this could potentially raise the question can women let their emotions towards followers get in the way of their tasks. A leader should do what they can to help their followers and that is not what Sheikh Hasina is doing for her country. However, I dont think that it comes down to whether women leaders matter or not. I think they do matter this just happens to be the case where this leader is not the best fit. This could have been a man leader doing the same thing. Do you think that women leaders matter?
Marcus Campbell
In this article it talks about if women leaders really do matter. As stated in the last post by Eric, women are transformational types of leaders and care about the feelings of their followers. But, does a women leader always do the right thing for their followers. This article states, "Bangladesh has a woman prime minister, Sheikh Hasina, who has done nothing much for women – and who now is pursuing a campaign of vilification against Muhammad Yunus, the Nobel Peace Prize winner who has been a champion of impoverished women all around the globe." To me this could potentially raise the question can women let their emotions towards followers get in the way of their tasks. A leader should do what they can to help their followers and that is not what Sheikh Hasina is doing for her country. However, I dont think that it comes down to whether women leaders matter or not. I think they do matter this just happens to be the case where this leader is not the best fit. This could have been a man leader doing the same thing. Do you think that women leaders matter?
Marcus Campbell
Does Gender Matter?
http://womensissues.about.com/od/intheworkplace/a/WomenLeaders.htm
Ebay President and Ceo Meg Whitman has several quotes in this article about why women can be better leaders than men. We talked about how women leaders are more assertive and hold a more transformational style of leadership and that's exactly what Meg stated in the article.
Eric Dhooge
Ebay President and Ceo Meg Whitman has several quotes in this article about why women can be better leaders than men. We talked about how women leaders are more assertive and hold a more transformational style of leadership and that's exactly what Meg stated in the article.
"Women leaders are more assertive and persuasive, have a stronger need to get things done and are more willing to take risks than male leaders....Women leaders were also found to be more empathetic and flexible, as well as stronger in interpersonal skills than their male counterparts....enabl[ing] them to read situations accurately and take information in from all sides....These women leaders are able to bring others around to their point of view....because they genuinely understand and care about where others are coming from....so that the people they are leading feel more understood, supported and valued."In transformational leadership there are two main differences in men and women:
- women's styles tend to be more transformational
- women tend to engage in more contingent reward behaviors
Eric Dhooge
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)