Monday, March 21, 2011

Are most leaders evil?


The article above asks the questions why are so many “evil leaders” at the top of many organizations. I don’t think that the leaders the author is referring to are evil, but instead they are probably transactional leaders, (9,1) Authority Compliance on the Managerial grid, and definitely do not place much focus on relationships. Transactional leadership focuses on the exchanges that occur between leaders and followers, where as transformational leadership is a process whereby a person engages with others and creates a connection that raises the level of motivation and morality in both the leader and the follower (Northouse). If this author’s assumption is right  then the author is saying that most powerful leaders are transactional. If he is right then powerful leaders also do not place much attention to building relationships in the workplace. I personally disagree with the author because I think that it’s important for leaders to practice transformational leadership over transactional leadership. I think the reason the author feels this is way is because he doesn’t think that many leaders focus on relationships, and only focus on the tasks that need to be accomplished. I think the reason he thinks this is because many leaders who are high in organizations are hard workers and very motivated so they may be perceived as a jerk or “evil”. One example is Steve Jobs, who we talked about in class. This author and many other people probably perceive him as evil because of his persona. Others however define him as transformational because his tactics could be seen as extremely motivational.  Do you agree with the author that there are many “evil leaders” high up in organizations, or do you think he is over reacting? Also, do you know of any examples where transformational leaders with good ethics are successful (because apparently this author cannot)?
Jack Kalita
Team 5

Unethical Leader


The article above is about a controversial leader Hashim Thaci, being appointed president of Kosovo for the second time.  This doesn’t seem to make much sense because parliament walked out in disgust when they realized Thaci was to become appointed for a second term.  This seems extremely unethical because Thaci has been involved in a lot of illegal and unethical business in the past. As the article states, Thaci was linked to organized crime and organ trafficking in Europe last month.
            As our book states, ethics are concerned with the kinds of values and morals an individual or society fins desirable or appropriate.  It is pretty evident that the people of Kosovo are outraged by Thaci becoming president again. Many of the members or parliament did not even participate in the vote because they knew Thaci was going to win anyway, so they walked out in rebellion. It is pretty clear that Thaci is participating with the ethical egoism approach to moral conduct. There are three different approaches, ethical egoism, utilitarianism, and altruism.  Ethical egoism states that a person will act to create the greatest good for herself or himself. Utilitarianism states that leaders should behave to create the greatest good for the greatest overall number of people. The idea of altruism states that a leader’s actions are moral if their primary purpose is to promote the best interests of others.  It is pretty clear that Thaci’s approach is neither utilitarian nor altruistic, considering almost half of parliament walked out during the vote for the president. Thaci is definitely acting with ethical egoism. He clearly does not care about the people of Kosovo, and acts in selfish, sometimes illegal ways. He has been involved in several illegal/unethical crimes and has not provided the leadership the people of Kosovo need. What do you think about Hashim Thaci being appointed president? Do you think it can be argued that this is somehow ethical?
Jack Kalita
Team 5

Sunday, March 20, 2011

Do Women Leaders Matter?

http://kristof.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/03/08/do-women-leaders-matter/

In this article it talks about if women leaders really do matter. As stated in the last post by Eric, women are transformational types of leaders and care about the feelings of their followers. But, does a women leader always do the right thing for their followers. This article states,  "Bangladesh has a woman prime minister, Sheikh Hasina, who has done nothing much for women – and who now is pursuing a campaign of vilification against Muhammad Yunus, the Nobel Peace Prize winner who has been a champion of impoverished women all around the globe." To me this could potentially raise the question can women let their emotions towards followers get in the way of their tasks. A leader should do what they can to help their followers and that is not what Sheikh Hasina is doing for her country. However, I dont think that it comes down to whether women leaders matter or not. I think they do matter this just happens to be the case where this leader is not the best fit. This could have been a man leader doing the same thing. Do you think that women leaders matter?

Marcus Campbell

Does Gender Matter?

http://womensissues.about.com/od/intheworkplace/a/WomenLeaders.htm

Ebay President and Ceo Meg Whitman has several quotes in this article about why women can be better leaders than men. We talked about how women leaders are more assertive and hold a more transformational style of leadership and that's exactly what Meg stated in the article.
"Women leaders are more assertive and persuasive, have a stronger need to get things done and are more willing to take risks than male leaders....Women leaders were also found to be more empathetic and flexible, as well as stronger in interpersonal skills than their male counterparts....enabl[ing] them to read situations accurately and take information in from all sides....These women leaders are able to bring others around to their point of view....because they genuinely understand and care about where others are coming from....so that the people they are leading feel more understood, supported and valued."
In transformational leadership there are two main differences in men and women:
  • women's styles tend to be more transformational
  • women tend to engage in more contingent reward behaviors
If this is true about women and they say all women are doing a good job in their positions, maybe we should try to involve more women in upper level positions.

Eric Dhooge

Not Getting the Job Done

http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=6236160

In this article it talks about how NFL commissioner Roger Goodell is not making progress with the NFLPA in making sure there is no lockout this season. The NFL is possibly not going to have a season this year because of the unsettled differences between players and owners. Rodger Goodell is one of the individuals that isn'y making the greatest effort to garuntee the season either. I would consider Roger Goodell a Impoverished Manager becuase according to the managerial grid, it states that Impoverished managers have low concern for people and production. It seems as if he doesnt care about whether or not there will be a season. He gives players false hopes and he takes his time with meetings and gets no where. Impoverished management is the exertion of minimum effort to get required work doneis appropriate tosustain organization membership. Mr. Goodell isn't even doing that. He is doing minimal work but he isn't getting work done. What are your thoughts? Do you think he is taking the rights steps to prevent the lockout?

Marcus Campbell

Walgreens Team

Many of us know of the company Walgreens. They are a nation wide company that provides a wide variety of products for customers. I have worked for Walgreens for the past three years and what not many people know is how much Walgreens top management is is very team oriented. According to the managerial grid team management is work accomplished is from committed people; interdependence through a "common stake" in a organization purpose leads to relationships of trust and respect. Team management rates as (9,9) which means a high concern for production as well as for people. Walgreens is in the midst of changing all of their store to be more customer friendly. This is a long process of lowering shelves and moving products around so that there is nothing highr than 5 and 1/2 feet off the ground. By doing this it allows for older customers to shop freely and not have any risk of reaching for high products. This shows great concern for customers because a lot of the time if you can't reach it you wont get it so by doing this Walgreens is able to gain more sales. Concern for production is also another big factor that Walgreens uses. Everything that occurs in the workplace is not individual it is a team. That are all about efficiency and making sure things are done and done on time. We call ourselves the Walgreens team. Within the last year we added a new position called the Store Team Lead. Walgreens is a very good company and their top management is making changes to try and make it better. That is why I would give them a (9,9) rating. Do you agree that these changes are going to be better for them? Or do you think that there are other things that need to be done first?

Eric Dhooge

Saturday, March 19, 2011

Are Women More Ethical than Men?

Are women really more ethical than men?

I came across this article from the Journal of Managerial Issues that tackles the question, "Are women more ethical than men?" In class we learned that women are more likely to use a participative or democratic style of leadership and are found to be more transformational leaders than men, but does being a female make you more ethical? At first thought, men are considered to be more unethical because men hold the majority of executive positions in companies. With the rise in the number of females breaking through the glass ceiling the attention to the relationship between gender and ethical decision making is also on the rise. Several studies on the issue of whether women and men respond to ethical dilemmas did not detect any significant differences due to gender and those studies that did find a difference, were very mixed.


Do you feel that women are more ethical than men? or vice versa?


Dave Holloway