The article above asks the questions why are so many “evil leaders” at the top of many organizations. I don’t think that the leaders the author is referring to are evil, but instead they are probably transactional leaders, (9,1) Authority Compliance on the Managerial grid, and definitely do not place much focus on relationships. Transactional leadership focuses on the exchanges that occur between leaders and followers, where as transformational leadership is a process whereby a person engages with others and creates a connection that raises the level of motivation and morality in both the leader and the follower (Northouse). If this author’s assumption is right then the author is saying that most powerful leaders are transactional. If he is right then powerful leaders also do not place much attention to building relationships in the workplace. I personally disagree with the author because I think that it’s important for leaders to practice transformational leadership over transactional leadership. I think the reason the author feels this is way is because he doesn’t think that many leaders focus on relationships, and only focus on the tasks that need to be accomplished. I think the reason he thinks this is because many leaders who are high in organizations are hard workers and very motivated so they may be perceived as a jerk or “evil”. One example is Steve Jobs, who we talked about in class. This author and many other people probably perceive him as evil because of his persona. Others however define him as transformational because his tactics could be seen as extremely motivational. Do you agree with the author that there are many “evil leaders” high up in organizations, or do you think he is over reacting? Also, do you know of any examples where transformational leaders with good ethics are successful (because apparently this author cannot)?
Jack Kalita
Team 5
I think the author is over reacting. Though I do believe he is not far off to say there are some evil leaders out there. To answer your question, I think Martin Luther King Jr. would be an example of a picture perfect ethical transformational leader.
ReplyDeleteSteven Trilikis
I also agree that the author is overreacting, however, some CEO's are perceived as evil because of some of the things people must do to reach such an elite level within an organization. You cannot please everybody and sometimes have play a political game, and some people perceive that as being evil.
ReplyDeleteDan Shelhamer