Monday, April 11, 2011

Good and Bad Leaders

http://www.theocentric.com/ecclesiology/leadership/bad_leadership.html

This article differentiates good and bad leaders, but also makes the point that no leadership can be good without "good" followers. Although I feel that this article makes some interesting points I feel that it fails to notice the situational approach to leadership. As we know this leadership approach argues that leaders must match their style to the competence and commintment of their subordinates. The author of this article says "Bad leaders are bad because they are either ineffective or unethical – or both". I agree that there are bad leaders out there because they do not have the neccessary skills to be a good leader, or that there are those leaders that are unethical which makes them bad. However I do feel that there are situations where the leader can be viewed as "bad" becuase they were put in the wrong situation. Some leaders are more supportive and others are more directive, but if put in the wrong situations their followers may not meet their needs. Do you think it is the organizations responsibility to put certain people in leadership roles that fit the followers, or do you think that it is the leaders responsibility to act in ways they are not comfortable in to provide followers with the type of leadership they need to succeed.

Team 5
Jack Kalita

1 comment:

  1. To answer your question entirely, I would say a little bit of both. It would be completely unfair and injustice for an individual to be put in a situation with very little chance of success. However, every organization's goal is to be successful both ethically and financially. If the last resort is to put an inidividual leader in an awdward situation, then that action should be taken. However, if other options are available with the same or better chance of success and no individuals are being put in bad situations, then those actions need to be taken instead.

    Marcus Campbell

    ReplyDelete